الصوت مش محتاج إذن. ✳ مجلة نسوية مصرية مستقلة ✳
Back →

النسوية والمجتمع

Is Cohabitation a Product of Patriarchy and Toxic Masculinity?

Does cohabitation liberate women from marriage, or can it release men from marital responsibilities while preserving patriarchal privileges? A feminist examination of intimacy, power and unpaid labour.

من غير إذن
تصميم جرافيكي بخلفية نبيتي داكنة، تتكرر عليها أشكال دائرية وردية ذات ملمس خشن وتفاصيل متعرجة. في المنتصف مستطيل بلون كريمي يحمل العبارة «هل المساكنة بتحرر المرأة» بخط عربي عريض باللون النبيتي.

Does feminism liberate women from the institution of marriage, or can it become a justification for freeing men from marital responsibilities while preserving their privileges?

Is Cohabitation a Product of Patriarchy and Toxic Masculinity? Does feminism liberate women from the institution of marriage, or can it become a justification for freeing men from marital responsibilities while preserving their privileges?

Ideas presented in the language of freedom and liberation can sometimes reproduce the very gender hierarchies they claim to challenge. The structure of a relationship changes, but traditional expectations, unequal responsibilities and patriarchal power dynamics remain.

This raises an important question: does abandoning marriage automatically liberate a relationship from patriarchy?

Roqa: The Woman Who Pays the Price

In the Egyptian film Al Aar (1982), Roqa can be read as a representation of the woman idealised by patriarchal expectations: loving, obedient, supportive and willing to sacrifice her own interests.

The problem is not love or care themselves. It begins when these qualities become duties demanded disproportionately from women without equal reciprocity.

If the marriage contract disappears but all the traditional expectations placed upon women remain, what has actually changed?

Changing the Institution or Just Its Appearance?

Imagine a man and woman choosing to live together without getting married.

The man may not assume the same formal obligations associated with marriage, while the woman is still expected to cook, clean, provide emotional care and shoulder most household responsibilities.

Such a relationship may appear progressive but still reproduce a patriarchal division of labour.

This does not mean that cohabitation is inherently exploitative or that marriage guarantees fairness. It means that liberation cannot be measured by relationship labels alone.

Nawal El Saadawi: Freedom Requires Material Independence

Egyptian feminist Nawal El Saadawi connected women's liberation to economic independence, political rights, knowledge and genuine decision-making power.

In an interview, she explained:

"Within a household, the individual woman must have power."

This power requires more than the formal freedom to make a choice. It also depends on resources, rights and the realistic ability to leave an unequal relationship.

A feminist analysis must therefore consider not only whether a woman voluntarily enters cohabitation, but also the conditions shaping her independence within it.

Silvia Federici: When Love Becomes Unpaid Labour

In her 1975 essay Wages Against Housework, Silvia Federici wrote:

"They say it is love. We say it is unwaged work."

Federici challenged the assumption that housework and care are naturally women's responsibilities rather than socially organised labour.

Her critique remains relevant outside marriage.

A woman may perform the same unpaid domestic and emotional labour in a cohabiting relationship, even when that relationship presents itself as an alternative to traditional marriage.

The absence of a contract does not automatically create an equal distribution of work.

Mona Eltahawy and the Persistence of Patriarchal Power

Mona Eltahawy's criticism of patriarchal authority offers another perspective: challenging oppressive institutions also requires confronting the everyday behaviours and privileges that sustain them.

A couple can reject marriage while continuing to treat emotional care as a woman's duty, freedom as a man's entitlement and sacrifice as proof of feminine love.

In that situation, the appearance of the relationship changes while its underlying power structure remains intact.

Cohabitation in Egypt: Who Carries the Risk?

In Egypt, cohabitation raises additional social and legal questions.

Women may face disproportionate stigma surrounding relationships outside marriage, while unmarried cohabitation does not automatically confer the legal rights associated with recognised marriage.

This creates the possibility that women retain traditional domestic burdens without enjoying some of the legal protections available to spouses.

However, these are structural risks, not proof that every cohabiting relationship is exploitative. Direct representative evidence about unmarried cohabiting couples in Egypt remains limited.

Marriage itself also contains gender inequalities. Legal recognition does not automatically guarantee safety, autonomy or equality.

Can Cohabitation Be Liberating?

Cohabitation is neither inherently patriarchal nor inherently feminist.

It can provide space for more equal relationships, negotiated responsibilities and greater personal autonomy. It can also reproduce traditional gender roles under a different name.

The meaningful measure of liberation is not whether a marriage certificate exists, but how care, labour, money, power and responsibilities are distributed.

We can abolish the marriage contract while preserving every patriarchal expectation associated with it.

Any relationship that demands women's care, labour and sacrifice without fair and reciprocal responsibilities deserves feminist scrutiny, whatever its name.

Real liberation is not simply the absence of a contract. It is the absence of entitlement and subordination.

So the question remains: can cohabitation challenge patriarchy, or does it risk reproducing it in a different form?