Your voice doesn't need permission. ✳ Independent Egyptian feminist magazine ✳
← Back

ANALYSIS / GENDER & CULTURE

The Patriarchy Wears Lip Gloss

From kohl in ancient Egypt to modern lipstick ads, how did history and marketing make makeup a marker of femininity?

Long-form featureRAW by Vee
Original cover for The Patriarchy Wears Lip Gloss

Post summary

“Who put gender in the makeup kit?” The post follows the story from kohl in ancient Egypt to the marketing of eyeliner, lipstick, and lip gloss as products for women.

“Eyeliner, lip gloss, and lipstick are mostly marketed to women today” is an observation about the market and the culture we live in. Saying those products are inherently female and that a man who uses them is less of a man, or that they tell you who he’s attracted to, makes a much bigger claim. A company putting Women on the packaging gives you no biological, historical, or psychological evidence for that claim.

The relationship between makeup and gender has changed across time, class, and culture. Men and women wore kohl in ancient Egypt. Upper-class men in parts of Europe and America also wore face cosmetics at different points in history. And the World Health Organization distinguishes gender expression from sex, gender identity, and sexual orientation. So what gives a product a feminine or masculine meaning in a particular society? And how did those meanings become so familiar that they started to feel like properties of the products themselves?

What does the historical evidence actually show?

Start with ancient Egypt. The British Museum describes men and women wearing makeup and jewellery, including black kohl to define the eyes and darken the eyelashes. The Metropolitan Museum of Art has a New Kingdom kohl tube from around 1550–1300 BCE that belonged to Djehutymose, a man who held a senior religious position. The Met also has a kohl jar from the burial of the scribe Amenemhat and describes kohl as eye makeup used by men and women. Another jar from the Middle Kingdom comes with a similar account of cosmetics as part of grooming for both sexes.

In ancient Egypt, kohl could be associated with adornment, ritual, status, and perceived protective or medicinal effects. It had a similar function to modern eyeliner, even though the formula, packaging, and industry that give us Maybelline eyeliner or MAC lipstick came thousands of years later.

The same care applies to lip colour. Archaeological and textual evidence points to the use of red pigments on the face and lips in the ancient world. A 2024 study in Scientific Reports identified a red substance from southeastern Iran, dated to about 1936–1687 BCE, as a lip-colouring preparation with similarities to some modern lipstick formulas. The researchers couldn’t establish who used it or what their sex was. Bronze Age burials at Xiaohe in Xinjiang yielded red cosmetic sticks. A separate study of a Tang-era preparation found beeswax and other ingredients consistent with a cosmetic for the face or lips.

Across these examples, face and lip colour appear as varied cultural practices. When men wearing dark pigment around their eyes is ordinary in one society and frowned upon in another, that tells us something about the societies and what they read into the same gesture.

Lipstick and lip gloss have a more complicated history

People were colouring their lips long before commercial lipstick. The modern product grew out of mass production, work with pigments, waxes, and oils, and packaging that made it easy to carry and apply. The Smithsonian’s National Museum of American History dates the shift from paper packaging toward metal cases to around 1915. William G. Kendall received a patent in 1917 for a tube with a movable holder that pushed the stick out. Popular accounts often credit Maurice Levy with inventing the lipstick tube in 1915. The records are mixed on that attribution, while Kendall’s patent gives us a dated primary source. Modern metal lipstick packaging developed over that decade.

Max Factor dates its Lip Pomade, later known as lip gloss, to April 1928. According to the company, it was developed to give actresses’ lips a shine that would look good on camera. That Hollywood history helps explain why the product became so closely associated with femininity in the twentieth century.

Lipstick became a visible part of the way film and advertising pictured modern womanhood in the 1920s and 1930s. The V&A points to its place in Elizabeth Arden’s image in the 1930s. The Smithsonian describes how portable packaging, movies, and flapper culture helped make visible makeup more acceptable and widespread among women. The same museum describes eighteenth-century upper-class men and women in America wearing makeup, and a decline in the social acceptability of visible colour for both after the American Revolution. Research published by Cambridge also documents elite French men using rouge and other cosmetics in the eighteenth century. Critics accused makeup of feminising men. By the end of that century, coloured makeup had become less common among men, who continued to buy face creams and hair products. The rules about how a man is expected to look have a history of their own.

What changed during the Second World War?

The association between makeup and femininity predates the war. In nineteenth-century America, visible makeup was sometimes associated with vulgarity or sex work. Women who wanted to appear respectable were expected to achieve a “natural” look by subtler means. From the late nineteenth to the early twentieth century, beauty companies increasingly marketed to women. As more women earned their own money and entered the workforce, the consumer market expanded. In the 1920s, movies, flapper culture, and portable packaging helped make lipstick and rouge visible signs of modern femininity.

The war reinforced a particular version of femininity in American culture. The Smithsonian documents millions of women entering the workforce alongside recruitment campaigns and ads showing workers and nurses in lipstick and mascara. Women could take on new jobs and were still expected to look conventionally feminine. The museum notes that around 80–90% of American women used lipstick after the war. Revlon and Avon benefited from an already established habit. The war helped widen mass consumption and deepen the connection between cosmetics and the image of the modern woman.

Gendered marketing and consumer capitalism

Companies sell products along with ideas about who buys them and what that purchase says about them. Advertisers assign gender to products through colour, naming, packaging, casting, language, photography, the benefits they emphasise, and the tone they use. A review of advertising studies from 1973 to 2019 identified at least 22 types of cues used to gender products. A 2025 study in the Journal of Marketing Research found that removing explicit binary gender cues from marketing can reduce how much shoppers rely on gender stereotypes when evaluating products.

A razor may be sold as “for men” or “for women” even though it performs the same basic task. A U.S. government study of gender-differentiated products found that companies often vary attributes like colour or scent to address men and women as separate markets. This is market segmentation. A company identifies audiences and designs a product, its packaging, or its message to appeal to the people it wants to reach. “For women” on an eyeliner box tells us how a company chose to position it.

Advertising and culture influence each other. Ads borrow from existing norms and reinforce them through repetition. Social change can also push advertisers to change the people and roles they portray. History, fashion, commerce, and culture all contribute to the way we learn to read a product as masculine or feminine.

Patriarchy and hegemonic masculinity

In gender studies, patriarchy is a framework for examining power and the ways social structures assign different degrees of authority and value to masculine and feminine roles.

R. W. Connell’s work on hegemonic masculinity, developed further with James Messerschmidt, describes multiple masculinities. In a particular place and time, one model tends to be held up as the most respectable or legitimate way to be a man, even when most men fall short of it. Rules like “don’t cry,” “don’t look sensitive,” and “don’t wear that colour” show how this ideal can be enforced through ordinary interactions. The World Health Organization also links rigid expectations of masculinity to effects on men’s health and behaviour, including avoiding health care and taking risks.

“If a man wears lipstick, gloss, or eyeliner, he’s not a man.”

Sociologically, that remark can be read as policing masculinity. It tries to enforce a boundary around acceptable appearance. The research offers a way to interpret the remark without assuming that the person saying it is aware of the framework or deliberately defending a system. A social convention can tell you how a community responds to someone’s appearance. Sex, identity, and attraction are separate questions.

Sex, gender identity, gender expression, and sexual orientation

The World Health Organization distinguishes several concepts that often get mixed together in discussions about makeup.

Sex refers to biological and physiological characteristics, including those associated with chromosomes, hormones, and reproductive anatomy.

Gender refers to roles, norms, behaviours, and characteristics a society associates with men and women. These vary across societies and over time.

Gender identity is a person’s internal experience of their gender.

Gender expression is how a person presents themselves socially, including through clothing, appearance, and speech.

Sexual orientation describes patterns of emotional, romantic, or sexual attraction. The WHO says orientation cannot be assumed from sex assigned at birth, gender identity, or gender expression.

Seeing a man wear eyeliner tells you he chose to wear eyeliner. Assuming he is gay, that he has a particular gender identity, or that he is less of a man relies on a stereotype. A straight man may wear makeup. A gay man may never wear it. Someone may wear lipstick for fashion, performance, as part of a subculture, or because they like the way it looks. An ID card may record a person’s sex. The choice of a cosmetic is still theirs.

What does “for women” on a package tell us?

A label like Women usually tells you two things. The company is targeting women, and the packaging is part of the strategy it uses to connect the product with that audience. The leap from “marketed to women” to “a man who uses this can’t be a man” needs evidence of its own.

A moisturiser labelled Men still moisturises. Pour Homme on a fragrance signals the audience and the associations the company wants people to make with the scent. A razor marked For Women still shaves if a man uses it. All three labels carry information about the market the product was designed for.

Across the examples from ancient Egypt, eighteenth-century America, and France, the same kinds of grooming were available to different people at different times. In the twentieth century, the growth of the women’s beauty market, cinema, and advertising gave particular cosmetics a strong feminine association. Lipstick is still widely read as feminine today. A cultural association tells us how a product is understood in a society and can change with it.

Gendered marketing, the pink tax, and pinkwashing

Gendered marketing or gendered product positioning describes packaging a product in pink for women and black for men, or printing “for her” and “for him” on the label. It includes all the choices about colour, language, imagery, design, and messaging that make products feel intended for a particular gender.

The pink tax refers to cases where goods or services marketed to women cost more than comparable ones marketed to men. A New York City study compared nearly 800 products and found that products targeted at women were more expensive on average across the categories examined. The U.S. Government Accountability Office cautioned that prices can also reflect size, features, demand, and production costs. The term describes a pattern worth investigating in specific comparisons.

Pinkwashing, as commonly used in LGBTQ+ contexts, criticises organisations that display superficial or selective support for LGBTQ+ rights to improve their image or profit without meaningful commitment. A “Women” label on eyeliner is an example of gendered marketing. A price premium on a comparable product may raise a pink tax question. Superficial Pride branding for reputational gain may be an example of pinkwashing.

What the evidence shows and how we interpret it

Historical evidence shows that face cosmetics were used by men and women in ancient Egypt and at various points in Europe and America. Lip colour is ancient. Modern lipstick and lip gloss have their own industrial histories, including Max Factor’s 1928 account of Lip Pomade.

Marketing research shows how packaging, advertising, language, and images give products a gendered meaning. Gender and health research distinguishes the way a person presents themselves from sex, gender identity, and sexual orientation. The social interpretation is that we learn what counts as masculine or feminine from norms that develop and change over time, then get reinforced through institutions and commercial practices. Hegemonic masculinity gives us one way to understand the narrow rules some communities apply to men’s appearance.

“I don’t like it” is a statement of taste. Saying a man is less of a man for wearing lipstick is a claim about him. Similarly, saying lipstick is widely associated with femininity describes a culture. Saying it can only be worn by women turns that observation into a biological claim.

Lipstick has no sex. Eyeliner has no sexual orientation. Lip gloss can’t measure masculinity. The history of cosmetics gives us plenty of examples of people giving the same practice different meanings.

References

Museums and historical sources

British Museum — Looking Good in Ancient Egypt
The Metropolitan Museum of Art — Kohl Tube and Applicator
The Metropolitan Museum of Art — Kohl Jar
Smithsonian National Museum of American History — Make-up
V&A — Giving Face: Women’s Make-up Style and Status in the 1930s
Max Factor — Our Heritage
Smithsonian National Museum of American History — Richard Hudnut Lipstick Case
U.S. Patent — W. G. Kendall, Lip-stick Holder, 1917

Archaeology and history

Eskandari et al., Scientific Reports — A Bronze Age lip-paint from southeastern Iran
Yang et al. — Characterization of cosmetic sticks at Xiaohe Cemetery
Martin, Cambridge University Press — Doctoring Beauty: The Medical Control of Women’s Toilettes in France, 1750–1820

Gender and marketing

Sandhu — Gendering Products Through Advertisements
Yin, Li & Su — The Effect of Gender-Neutral Marketing on Consumer Attribute Preference
Connell & Messerschmidt — Hegemonic Masculinity: Rethinking the Concept
World Health Organization — Gender and Health

Pink tax and pinkwashing

New York City — From Cradle to Cane: The Cost of Being a Female Consumer
U.S. Government Accountability Office — Gender-Related Price Differences
Collins English Dictionary — Pinkwashing

Original reading text and source link are preserved. TikTok embeds load on request.

Open original post ↗